A few
scientists, from the various part of the world, came to
Puttaparthi, India, to study and experience Baba, from
the year 1974 onwards, motivated by a famous scientist,
Erlendur Haraldsson, an Associate Professor of
Psychology at the University of Iceland and currently a
visiting professor at the University of Virginia School
of Medicine, USA. He has published a number of research
papers on Psychology and parapsychology and is author of
'At the hour of Death' with Karlis Osis (Hasting House,
New York) which has been translated into fourteen
languages.
Haraldsson's book,
'Miracles Are My Visiting Cards' (An investigative report on the
Psychic Phenomena associated with Sathya Sai Baba), was published
in the year 1987. It is a foreign publication, but presently
available in India, at Sai Towers, Puttaparthi.
Haraldsson had done
an extensive research on Baba, and visited India several times,
during the course of his investigations. The book which runs into
300 pages, contains the details of his first-hand information,
evidence and experience.
The author would
like to mention a few of the incidents taken from Haraldsson's
book. They are as follws :
n Haraldsson writes
that Dr.V.K.Gokak, the former Vice Chancellor of Bangalore
University, narrated an incident: "In Jamnagar, a few of the
devotees were with Swami, in many cars. As we drove near the
coast, Swami stopped the cars and we went down the seashore. We
sat down in a crescent on the fresh sandy beach only a few yards
from the sea with Sai Baba sitting in the middle. Many of us had
come to this area from afar, and we were disappointed because we
had not been able to see Krishna in the temple. "Never mind"
Swami said, "I will show it to you". Then He drew with His hand a
figure on the sand in front of Him, a very sketchy figure of a
man. And then He put His hand into the sand and kept it there for
a minute and a half or two. "Aha, it is ready now", He said in
English, as this was a multinational group. Then He pulled out of
the sand this huge statue of Krishna.
It was so heavy that
He had to lift it with both hands. It was a golden statue. You can
see it with the Rajmata (Former queen) of Nawanagar in Bombay.
The statue was passed around, and all had to hold it with both
hands. Finally, He handed the statue to the Rajmata of Nawangar
for worship.
n He further writes,
"Sai Baba has been filmed extensively while producing objects
outdoors, and those present have reported seeing the same
movements as were recorded on the film. Also the objects that he
produced for us in the interviews (the double Rudraksha and the
golden ring with the enamel picture) are still in our possession
and were therefore not illusory. For these reasons we can
reasonably reject the hypothesis of hypnosis as an explanation for
the materialisation.
n Once Haraldsson
told Baba. "We are researchers of Psychic phenomena and have heard
many accounts of miracles occurring in His presence. As we were
talking , He again made with His right hand that typical small,
circular movement that lasts for two or three seconds, and lo
there was a large and shiny golden ring in His palm. He put it on
Dr.Osis' right finger and said it was for him. It fitted. (Set
into the ring was a large coloured picture of Sai Baba on a stone
or some similar material that was firmly encased by the ring. The
picture was oval in shape and portrayed a good likeness of his
face.)
n Haraldsson
writes, "By the time our second visit to India was over, Dr.Osis
and I had observed the ostensible paranormal appearances of
objects in Baba's hand about 29 times. None of these events
occurred under controlled conditions. Also, we were not able to
examine Sai Baba physically either to confirm or to refute the
hypothesis that he conceals objects on his body. At this stage,
therefore, we have insufficient grounds for accepting the claims
made about the genuineness (in terms of paranormal process) of the
reported phenomena. But it must also be stated that we detected no
evidence of fraud.
I made six more
journeys to India, the first in 1976 and the last in 1983, each
lasting one to four months. In four of these eight journeys, I was
accompanied twice by Dr. Osis, once for three months by
Dr.Michael Thalbourn of Washington University, and once for a
month by Dr. Joop Houtkooper of the University of Amsterdam.
Once in the midst
of our rather heated discussion, Sai Baba impatiently said to Dr.
Osis: "Look at your ring". We did. The enamel picture on the ring
had disappeared. The large golden ring that Sai Baba had presented
to Dr. Osis during our first visit was on the ring finger of his
left hand. The stone encased in it had on the top a large enameled
coloured picture of Sai Baba. The stone with the picture was
missing from the ring and we could see the bare skin of Dr. Osis'
finger through the hole. We looked for the picture on the floor,
but no trace of it could be found. For the picture to have fallen
out of the frame, it would have to be broken or it would have been
necessary to bend at least one of the prongs and probably also
bend the frame at some point, but the frame and the prongs were
undamaged.
When the picture
could not be found, Sai Baba somewhat teasingly remarked: "Well,
this was my experiment". Later he implied that this was a joke,
and then he added, "You asked for a miracle and I just gave it to
you".
Some years ago
Dr. Osis discussed our observations with Doug Henning. Mr.Henning
said that he could, with advance preparation, duplicate all the
phenomena he saw on the film. But when Dr. Osis described the
incident in which the enamel stone with Sai Baba's picture
disappeared from Dr. Osis' ring, Mr. Henning commented that this
was beyond the skills of the magicians. He stated further that if
Sai Baba produces objects on demand, then he is performing feats
that no magician can duplicate.
Where then is our
conclusion about the physical phenomena? For lack of experimental
evidence it can only be somewhat tentative, though the testimony
is extensive and consistent over four decades. Whether some of the
physical productions, in some periods of Baba's life, may have
been produced by sleight of hand, we can't, of course ascertain.
What we can, however, squarely state is that in spite of long
standing and painstaking efforts, we found no direct evidence of
fraud.
Baba is a man of
great unpredictable spontaneity. In 1980 I decided in an
interview, for a change, not to pester him with requests that he
had earlier turned down nor to argue with him about the necessity
for controlled research of his gifts as I was wont to do. Then he
seemed irritated and reprimanded me for not doing so. In the
interview room with me there were a few people that I had not
previously met. Apparently in a move to show me something special
he asked an elderly gentleman, who was sitting with us on the
floor for a ring he had on one of his fingers. He took it on his
hand, held it before our eyes and said to me, "See scientist,
within a minute I will change this into different size, style and
shape". He gave it to me to examine, took it back, blew on it
three times and handed me a ring that was markedly different.
Then he explained to those around him in boyish naivety and with
a triumphant look on his face "How science can explain this?"
DR. ROERICH
OBSERVED:
If we take India
as it stands today, the most popular phenomena is Sai Baba. There
is no doubt about this; He has millions of followers. From every
point of view, it is a positive movement, because He has given
happiness and faith to hundreds and thousands of people. Other
people should try to ensure that this faith is sustained because
this world certainly needs it in one form or another.
Whether you
agree that the phenomena Baba produces are necessary or not does
not make much difference. I accept the necessity of the phenomena
because from His point of view that is the quickest way to attract
people. If a teacher did not display these phenomena, he would not
make sufficient impact. There can be no doubt that Baba is a great
phenomenon.
This visit to
Puttaparthi was nice because everybody was happy, everybody
received something from Baba in one way or another, and the
visitors returned to their country with fine momentos of the
occasion.
(All the above
matter has been taken from the book 'Miracles are My Visiting
Cards' by Erlendur Haraldsson).
Here below is
the reproduction of the Foreword, written by Karlis Osis, for the
book 'Miracles are My Visiting Cards' by Haraldsson.
FOREWORD
'Miracles are My
Visiting Cards' has merits of unique proportions. Although
miraculous phenomena occurring in connection with the religious
leaders have been reported throughout history, Haraldsson's
presentation is a first of its kind. The study is based upon the
first hand observation of a scientist and is supported by his
careful interrogation of witnesses. It describes paranormal
phenomena of extraordinary variety and strength attributed to one
of the most remarkable men of the century.
India, the land
of Guru worship, abounds with holy men who are often called
'Baba'. Sathya Sai Baba is a unique individual - a kind of genius
towering over the whole landscape. He sees His mission as
primarily devoted to the spiritual and moral renewal of India -
extricating his country from its present confusions. Baba's
powerful influence, however, touches the whole fabric of Indian
life, be its social, justice, political problems, or the
educational system. The meek and the downtrodden, as well as the
powerful and mighty, flock around him in never-ending crowds
streaming through his Ashram. I was present when a person holding
one of the highest elected offices in India, escorted by a
General, approached him. They both got down on the floor and
touched Baba's feet with their foreheads.
Most Westerners
visiting India's Ashrams desire spiritual guidance and
enlightenment, but Haraldsson was attracted by something else: the
stories of Baba's paranormal phenomena describe power of
magnitude, variety and sustained frequency not encountered
anywhere else in the modern world. I have seen violent storms of
controversy about them on the front pages of publications all over
India. Indian journalists are as aggressive as their counterparts
anywhere in the world, but no one has been able to find tricks
behind his reported phenomena.
Is there some
truth behind the said phenomena? This book is the record of 10
years' work of a highly qualified European psychology professor
trying hard to find reliable answers. It was not easy for him.
Legends grow fast on the fertile soil of India, and observations
are often couched in religious terms, for example ESP(extra
sensory perception) becomes 'Baba's omniscience'. Sleight of hand
and other arts of the magician are well developed in India and
some famous Swamis don't mind resorting to them, as I have
personally observed Haraldsson is acutely aware of these other
explanations: Readers will see with what vigour he cuts through
the jungle of storytelling and candidly reports the outcome of his
quest.
Neither
Haraldsson nor I were able to persuade Baba to participate in
experiments. Nothing would have clinched the matter so well as,
say, a week or two spent in the best parapsychological
laboratories in the world, that we offered. Nevertheless I could
understand the reluctance of a religious leader of millions to
submit to experimental protocol designed by people of different
beliefs and cultures. After all no one asked the Pope to go to the
laboratory, before his Holiness could be trusted.
In the absence of
laboratory evidence Haraldsson states his reservations. In the
western tradition of experimental science nothing that has not
withstood by controlled experiment is considered certain. Many
social scientists, however, including myself, have later put more
trust in observations of real life events, which often reveal what
the lab distorts. Haraldsson wisely presents all sides and asks
intelligent readers to judge themselves.
Millions of
Baba's followers - East and West - call him Avatar, that is,
incarnation of a deity. This is by no means universally accepted
in India, just as Jesus, who is said to be incarnation of God, is
not universally accepted in the West. These matters of belief and
theological reasoning are clearly not in the domain of
parapsychology, and Haraldsson wisely avoids evaluation of the
religious side of the issues. The paranormal is what Haraldsson is
trying to document and understand; and even that - as the reader
will see - is not easy. Although some of the phenomena go
hand-in-hand with the Western concepts of, telepathy,
clairvoyance, foresight of future and mind over matter
(psychokinesis), there are other phenomena for which we are not
prepared. Translocations of objects and liquid substances, which
at times are said to have materialised, are not in the books of
modern parapsychology. Some of Baba's out-of-the-body experiences
seem to be similar to what we observe in our experiments, and to
what many Western people report, others are much more substantial
such as claims of the translocation or bilocation of his body -
flesh and bones.
Conceptualisations in scientific parapsychology do not go that
far. For something so mind-shattering and unique we need stronger
evidence than is usually required. Haraldsson wisely reports what
he has found so far and keeps the matter open for further research
developments. It would have been cowardly simply to ignore what so
many witnesses have said and what our own eyes have observed, just
because it is so out of the ordinary. I hope the research will go
on, impartially, wherever it leads. Some observations may be
explained away, others may lead to a deeper understanding of the
reality of the human mind, the real miracle behind miracles.
Most open-minded
readers, I feel, will be stimulated by this kind of knocking at
the very door of the unknown. Even those whose minds are not
receptive to these possibilities of the unexplored - be it
paranormal or be it spiritual - will not go away empty handed:
they at least will find something exciting to scoff at.
So daring a book
as 'Miracles Are My Visiting Cards' will mean many things to many
people because it presents carefully collected data, rather than
opinions, on one of the most remarkable men of our times. For some
it will be an unforgettable treat for the heart, for the others
food for thought. I personally felt vibrant excitement when
reading this book - so pregnant with unfold potentialities.
Karls Osis Ph.D.
Chester F.Carlson
Research Fellow
American Society
for Psychical Research
New York, NY,
USA.
The author would
like to conclude this chapter by saying :
Does the Sun need
any other light, to prove that there is light in the Sun. The Sun,
itself is the LIGHT. Same thing also applies to Baba. He is the
Sun, He is the LIGHT, He is the illuminator of all the SOULS.